Blog

Which Type of Time and Attendance System is Best for an Accounting Firm?

Blog
<< return to blog list



Which Type of Time and Attendance System is Best for an Accounting Firm?

Dec, 2023











For accounting firms, tracking time and attendance is crucial. Billable hours are the lifeblood of public accounting firms. Therefore, choosing the right time and attendance system is an important decision that can impact productivity, profitability, and growth.

In this blog post, we'll explore the key features accounting firms should look for in a time and attendance system. We'll also compare and contrast the pros and cons of different types of systems like paper-based, spreadsheet-based, standalone software, and cloud-based solutions. By the end, you'll have a better understanding of which time tracking system is the best fit for your accounting firm's unique needs.

Key Features Accounting Firms Should Look for in a Time and Attendance System

When evaluating time and attendance systems, accounting firms should look for these key features:

  • Accuracy: The system should allow staff to precisely track their time down to 6 minute increments. This level of accuracy is needed for billing purposes.
  • Multiple tracking options: Staff should be able to track time in the office, at client sites, on the go via mobile apps, etc.
  • Project tracking: The ability to tag time entries to specific projects and clients is critical.
  • Real-time reporting: Managers need real-time insight into billable hours by staff, client, project, etc. to make informed decisions.
  • Overtime management: The system should automatically flag overtime hours for approval and calculate overtime pay per labor laws.
  • Time off requests: Streamlining PTO requests and approvals saves payroll managers time.
  • Payroll integration: Seamless integration with payroll systems avoids manual errors in processing payroll.
  • Access controls: Managers should have the ability to restrict staff access to certain features or reports.
  • Mobile app: On-the-go time tracking via smartphones or tablets is no longer a luxury.

These features allow accounting firms to gain the insight needed to maximize billable hours and ensure payroll accuracy. The right time tracking system pays for itself through recouped revenue and productivity gains.

Paper-Based Timesheets

Paper timesheets used to be the default option for many businesses. However, they have some significant downsides for modern accounting firms.

Pros:

  • Simple and inexpensive to implement
  • Staff already understand how to use

Cons:

  • Difficult to track time to specific projects or clients
  • No way to set permissions or restrict access
  • Time-consuming data entry and recalculations required
  • Manual payroll processing leads to errors
  • No reporting functionality
  • No overtime alerts or PTO management features
  • No mobile capabilities

While paper timesheets are better than nothing, they create unnecessary administrative work and offer no insights into staff productivity. The chance of human error is also high. For these reasons, most modern accounting firms need a more robust attendance tracking solution.

Spreadsheet-Based Time Tracking

Using Microsoft Excel or Google Sheets to track time offers some improvements over paper-based records. But spreadsheets still come with limitations.

Pros:

  • Simple format staff already know how to use
  • Ability to customize columns and labels
  • Can add formulas to sum hours or calculate overtime pay
  • Sheets can be shared and accessed by managers

Cons:

  • Difficult to track time to specific projects
  • Lack of permissions - anyone with access can edit or delete data
  • Tedious to enter and update data
  • No automation - requires manual reconciliation with payroll
  • Limited reporting functionality
  • No mobile app
  • Higher risk of calculation errors

Spreadsheets work okay for very small teams but become unwieldy as staff count rises. The lack of access controls, validation rules, and automation make them a poor time tracking choice for larger accounting firms.

Standalone Time Tracking Software

For many years, standalone time and attendance software was the preferred choice for HR managers. However, cloud-based systems now offer better flexibility and mobility.

Pros:

  • Robust features for tracking, reporting, scheduling, etc.
  • Customizable fields, views and configuration settings
  • Can integrate with payroll, HR and billing systems
  • Access control and permissions
  • Provides alerts and notifications

Cons:

  • Installed locally - limited mobility and access
  • Requires manual software and server updates
  • Upfront software purchase and licensing fees
  • Less flexible scaling options

Traditional installed timekeeping systems require a significant upfront investment and internal IT resources to manage. This gives the modern cloud solutions an advantage for rapidly growing accounting firms.

Cloud-Based Time and Attendance Systems

Modern cloud-based time tracking solutions offer new levels of mobility, flexibility, and insight. They are especially well-suited for today's distributed, fast-paced accounting firms.

Pros:

  • Accessible from anywhere via web and mobile apps
  • Real-time visibility into staff hours and productivity
  • Automated overtime alerts and PTO management
  • Integrations with popular payroll, billing, ERP platforms
  • Regular feature updates and enhancements
  • Scales easily as your firm grows
  • No infrastructure or software to install
  • Pay-as-you-go pricing models

Cons:

  • Subscription fees
  • Reliant on internet connection

The pros of cloud timekeeping outweigh the cons for most modern organizations. Reduced administrative burden, deeper insights, and increased flexibility make the software-as-a-service model a compelling choice.

Recommendation

For most accounting firms today, a cloud-based time and attendance system is the best option. The ability to access real-time data and automate error-prone processes on both desktop and mobile makes cloud solutions a smart investment.

That said, we always recommend taking the time to evaluate your firm's unique needs and challenges. Develop a list of must-have features based on feedback from managers and staff who will use the system daily. Most vendors offer free trials and demos - take advantage of these to get hands-on experience before committing.

While the upfront investment may give some firms pause, the long-term benefits of maximizing billable hours, gaining data-driven insights, and eliminating manual processes quickly overshadow the costs. The right timekeeping system pays for itself through recouped revenue and saved time.

Key Considerations When Evaluating Time and Attendance Systems

To decide on the best time and attendance system for your accounting firm, consider these key factors:

Features

Make a list of must-have features based on your firm's pain points and growth goals. Common features to look for include:

  • Web and mobile apps
  • Project tracking
  • Overtime and PTO management
  • Real-time analytics and custom reports
  • Notifications and reminders
  • Access controls and permissions
  • Payroll, HRIS, billing integrations
  • Custom approval workflows

Evaluate solutions against your feature checklist. Cloud systems tend to offer more robust options out-of-the-box.

Ease of Use

Adoption is crucial - a time tracking system won't deliver ROI if staff don't use it consistently. Look for an intuitive interface with little to no training required. The system should fit seamlessly into employees' existing workflows.

Implementation and Support

How hands-on is the implementation process? How responsive is the vendor's support team? Look for a provider that offers implementation consulting and post-launch support to ensure you get maximum value from the system.

Data Security

For accounting firms, data protection is non-negotiable when choosing any SaaS platform. Be sure to inquire about the physical and digital security measures the vendor takes to safeguard your sensitive data. Many providers undergo independent audits such as SOC 2 to validate their security controls.

Cost

Timekeeping systems range widely in terms of cost depending on features, integrations, and customization capabilities. Most offer monthly subscription plans based on the number of users. You'll also want to consider any one-time setup and training costs.

While cost is important, the biggest value comes from recouping wasted hours and gaining insights to improve productivity. Don't make price the only deciding factor.

Scalability

As your accounting firm grows, can this solution scale cost-effectively? Look for systems that make it easy to add features and users as needed. The right software should grow with your business.

Data Integration

The ability to integrate your time tracking software with payroll, billing, ERP and other systems is key. This eliminates the need for manual data entry and reconciliation between platforms. Prioritize solutions that offer robust integration capabilities.

Mobility

In today's world, a modern timekeeping solution must offer mobile apps that allow staff to track time on the go. This allows for more accurate time data as employees can log hours in real-time from any location.

Making the Most of Your Time Tracking Investment

Once you've chosen and implemented your time and attendance system, follow these best practices to maximize the benefits:

Provide Training

Host kickoff training sessions and provide user guides and video tutorials to ensure everyone understands how to use the software's key features. Periodic refresher trainings help reinforce utilization. Assign "power users" to provide ongoing support.

Customize Settings

Take advantage of customization features to tailor the system to your firm's workflows and processes. For example, set up project codes, pay rules, workflows and notification settings.

Promote Adoption

Drive consistent utilization by setting expectations for staff to track all hours worked in the new system. Highlight the benefits of accurate time data for billing and payroll. Friendly reminders help reinforce new habits.

Review Data Frequently

Leverage reporting features to gain visibility into productivty trends, identify bottlenecks, adjust capacity, and inform other key decisions. Timely insights lose value if not reviewed regularly.

Tie to Performance Management

Incorporate time and attendance metrics into staff performance evaluations and incentive programs. This motivates utilization and highlights the value you place on time tracking.

Continuously Improve

Solicit ongoing user feedback to pinpoint issues and opportunities for improvement. Work closely with your vendor's customer success team to optimize system configuration and expand feature utilization over time.

Time Tracking System Vendors

Some top time tracking systems used by accounting firms include:

  • Replicon - Offers advanced features and global capabilities tailored for professional services and project-based businesses.
  • TSheets - Acquired by Quickbooks, seamlessly integrates with popular small business software.
  • TimeCamp - Ideal for small businesses, with a focus on ease of use and visual tracking.
  • Hubstaff - Provides productivity monitoring features beyond just time tracking.
  • Toggl - A flexible, affordable option with robust integrations and a free plan.
  • Harvest - A longtime favorite, integrates with popular PM and billing tools.

Be sure to thoroughly evaluate multiple vendors to find the best alignment with your firm's needs and priorities. Taking the time upfront to find the right platform saves headaches down the road.

Conclusion

An effective time and attendance system is no longer a luxury for modern accounting firms - it's a necessity. The ability to gain insights into staff productivity, automate error-prone processes, and have unified data across systems delivers major competitive advantages.

While the software investment may represent a cost, it pays dividends through increased revenue from improved billing efficiency and recouped hours. Perhaps most importantly, eliminating the hassles of manual processes saves everyone time, allowing staff to focus on high-value work.

By taking the time to evaluate solutions thoroughly, provide staff training, and drive ongoing engagement, accounting firms can maximize ROI from time tracking software and take their business performance to new heights.

<< return to blog list

Ready to use Open Time Clock?

Create a free account

Open Time Clock is a powerful and user-friendly online time clock software designed for businesses of all sizes. It offers a comprehensive set of features to effectively manage employee time and attendance. With real-time tracking capabilities, employers can monitor employee hours from anywhere, whether in the office or on the go. The system supports various functionalities such as timesheet management, payroll automation, project tracking, and scheduling. It includes advanced features like geofencing, facial recognition, and GPS tracking to ensure accurate attendance records and prevent time fraud. Open Time Clock provides secure data storage, reliable performance, and flexible access options via desktop, mobile devices, and browsers. With its intuitive interface and extensive reporting capabilities, businesses can streamline their time management processes and enhance productivity. Sign Up Now!